Tuesday 15 November 2011

The Stroke Order of the Chinese Characters

 Share this page: <http://goo.gl/GC2B9D>.
The Stroke Order of the Chinese Characters

Youxuan Wang
2011-12-05


Introduction

The present discussion presumes that the reader has already read my article "Five Basic Strokes and their Serial Code"and is familiar with both the names and serial codes of the strokes. Otherwise, please click here to read it.

In what follows, we will first introduce 7 general rules for ordering the stroke sequence of  the Chinese characters before we discuss another 7 supplementary rules. These two set of rules address two types of concerns. They will both be explained with examples.

The 7 general rules are:
A1
先横后竖
The horizontal goes before the vertical;
A2
先撇后捺
the throw-away goes before press-down;
A3
从上到下
from top to bottom;
A4
从左到右
from left to right;
A5
从外到内
from outside to inside;
A6
先中间后两边
from centre to the two sides; and
A7
先里头后封口
from contents before enclosure.
Each of the above seven general rules highlights a hierarchical relation in a binary opposition. By implications, the seven rules mention seven pairs of opposing terms:

(A1) Héng versus shù:
(A2) Piě versus :
(A3) Top versus bottom;
(A4)  Left versus right;
(A5)  Outside versus inside;
(A6) Centres versus periphery;
(A7) Contents versus enclosure.

When one stroke moving horizontally from left to right crosses another stroke falling vertically from top to bottom, which should go first? Similarly, when a diagonal line moving down from top-right to bottom-left joins or crosses another stroke sliding also diagonally - but only from top-left to bottom-right, which of the pair should be given primacy over the other? A1 states that when the héng is opposed to the shù, the former is given primacy over the latter. A2 indicates that when the p is opposed to the , the piě goes before . Thus, although there are as many as seven rules, the rules are organised by binary oppositions rather than random considerations.

The 7 supplementary rules are:
B1
点在上面或左上,先写
The dot is to be written first – if it appears at the top or top-left of a character.
B2
点在里面或右上,后写
The dot comes last – if it appears at the top-right or  if it hides itself inside a radical.
B3
右上包、左上包的,先外后里
Outside precedes inside – if there's a two-sided enclosure from top-right or from top-left.
B4
左下包围的,先里后外
Inside goes before outside – if there's a two-sided enclosure from bottom and left.
B5
上边未包围的,先里后外
Inside is given primacy over outside – if there's a three-sided enclosure opening at the top.
B6
下边未包围的,先外后里
Outside goes before inside – if it's a three-sided enclosure opening at the bottom.
B7
右边未包围的,先上后里再左下
Top goes first, followed by middle, then by bottom and finally by the left side – if the enclosure opens on the right side.

These 7 supplementary rules are not primarily organised by binary oppositions, but purport to deal with two main types of situations: (a) when there is a dot at one of the three points on the top side of the character (B1-B2) ;  (b) when there is an unclosed two-sided or three-sided enclosure in a character (B3-B7).

A. Seven general rules illustrated with examples
This section of the present article assumes that the reader knows the serial codes of the five classes of strokes. (Click here for a short article on this topic.) In the tables below, we will use three abbreviations:

Ch:             Character 汉字
P.R.:           Principal radical 部首
S.O.:           Stroke order 笔顺

A1. Horizontal goes before vertical – when the two strokes cross each other:
Ch.
P.R.
S.O.
Comment
2512
2512
12
12
121
(12)-1
121
(12)-1
112
112
511112
511112

A2. The piě (throw-away) goes before the  (press-down) when the two cross each other or join each other.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
134
1-(34)
34
34
3432
(34)-32
3455
(34)-55
34
34
3452
(34)-52
1134
11-(34)
4134
41-(34)
341234
(34)-1234

A3. From top to bottom – when one stroke is placed on top of another.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
111
1-1-1
丿
35234
3-5-34
52
5-2
342
34-2
41431251135
41431-2511-35
414312511
41431-2511

 A4. From left to right – when strokes are aligned side by side from left to right.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
321234
32-1234
322
3-2-2
123425111
1234-25111
122513511
12251-3511
321511
321-51j-1

A5. From outside to inside  - when there's a three-sided enclosure opening only at the bottom.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
253434
25-3434
354
35-4
 
251251
25  251
425251
425 251
3534
35-34

A6. From centre to the two sides – if the central stroke is longer than those on both sides.
 Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
341534
(3-41)-(5-34)
5344
(53)-(44)
”first.
21135
(2 -11)-(3-5)
234
2-(34)
252
2-(52)
4122344544
41-(22-34)-4544
52111534
5-(2111-(5-34))
2534
2-(5-34)
45534
(45)-(5-34)
21112111
(2-111)-(2 -111)

Note this rule does not apply to or as the stroke orders of these two characters are governed by B1 which we will soon discuss.

A7. From contents before enclosure

When writing the-class words, we would begin with the first two strokes of ""  (i.e., 25). Before closing "", we would then write the contents inside the enclosure. When the contents are completed, we close "" by writing its bottom héng ().
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
 
25112141
Do not hastily close "" until you have written "", "", "", or "".
2511351
2525125341
25431134551
21251
Although "" is not closed in itself, the whole word "" is closed. Therefore, the bottom long héng in ""  is counted as the last independent stroke. Please watch the animation of the stroke order of this word on the Online Handian Dictionary here: <http://www.zdic.net/zd/zi/ZdicE5Zdic87ZdicB8.htm>.

Note that in a complete enclosure like “”, the two sides on the left and bottom do not form a single-stroke “L-shaped” zhé. When counting its strokes and describing its stroke order, we should see ” as a complete closure, even though it belongs to the -class. In an open “, the zhé “L” (with a turning-point at bottom-left) is one single stroke. In the whole word  ” the zhé “L” is broken into two strokes.

B.  Seven supplementary rules illustrated with examples

B.1.  The dot is to be written down first –  if it appears at the top or top-left of a character.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
434
4-34
4373
4-373
44134
44-134
442
4-42
425
4-25
4544
4-5-44
4334
4-334 ()
55414
55-(4-14)
413734
4-13734

B.2. The dot is the last to be written down –  if it appears at the top-right or if it hides itself inside a radical.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
544
in the middle is the last stroke.
53544
at the top-right is the last stroke.
1354
at the top-right is the last stroke.
1534
at the top-right is the last stroke.
135534
at the top-right is the last stroke.
315134
at the top-right is the last stroke.
1344
at the top-right is the last stroke.
1554
in the middle is the last stroke.
11214
at the top-right is the last stroke.
13534
at the top-right is the last stroke.

B3. Outside precedes inside – if there's a two-sided enclosure from top-right or from top-left.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment




131214
131214
and
131344
13-1344
+
1332511234
13-(32511-234)
35251
35251
丿,
广
413121
413-121
广+
112154
112154
12511534
12511534
++
4134112534
41341-12534
+

B4.  Inside goes before outside – if there's a  two-sided enclosure from bottom-left.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
312154
3121-54;
” goes before “
53454
53454;
” goes before “
1135454
1135-454
431325111454
431325111-454

B5.  Inside is given primacy over outside – if there's a three-sided enclosure opening at top.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
3452
34-52
52413452
524134-52
252
2-52
255455452
2554554-52

B6.  Outside goes before inside – if it's a three-sided enclosure opening at bottom.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
2534
25-34
354
35-4
251251
25-1251
3534
35-34
35112
35-112

B7.  Top goes first, which is to be followed by middle strokes, then by bottom strokes, and finally by strokes on the left side – if the enclosure opens on the right side.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
1345
134-5
1355
135-5
133125
13312-5
1311345
131134-5
1515
151-5
43123453312
(431234-5)-3312

Although “” (15) is a radical, its second stroke “ (5) has to wait until all the strokes inside its enclosure have been written down. Thus, the stroke order of ” is not 1535 (, ), but 1355 ().

C. Exercises
C1. Give the PR and stroke order of each of the following words:
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order



































C2. The stroke orders of the following words are somewhat difficult. Please look them up in the Handian Online Dictionary (Click here: <http://www.zdic.net/zd/>), and watch the animations of their stroke order thereon.
Ch.
PR
Stroke Order
Comment
丿
53
丿,
(Cf. )
21251
Note that the whole word is a complete enclosure.
35
丿,
3-54
丿,
(Cf. )
544
54-4
45512
45 () -512 (㇈, )
(Note that the last two strokes are a heng and a shu.)
153
1-53 (, 丿)
1225125112512511
12-251()-251()-1-251()-251()-1.
43252343134
43-25-234-3134
()
4153
41-53 (, 丿)
4134342511
4134342511
(two dots on the top-left, followed by two dots on the top-right, then "", and finallt "" (= “” )
11212154
11()-2121()-54 (㇂, )
4334
43-34 ()
13434343434
1-(3434-3434)-34
(一人)
55212534
Top: 5()-5()-1()-3(丿)
55414
55-414
543341251431
Top: 54-334
Bottom: 1251-43-1
3215112512153
(321-51-1)-25121-53
3444445235
34-4444-52-35
(×→ 4 )


Bibliography

Official publication:
Guójiā Yǔyān-wénzì Gōngzuò-wěiyuánhuì 国家语言文字工作委员会 PRC National Commission for Language Standardization. Xiàndài hànyǔ tōngyòngzì bǐshùn guīfàn 《现代汉语通用字笔顺规范》(Standard stroke orders of most commonly used modern Chinese characters. Beijing 北京:Yǔwén Chūbǎnshè 语文出版社 (Language Press)1997. URL: <http://china-and-west.blogspot.com/2011/11/blog-post_05.html>

Internet resources:
"Animation of stroke order". URL: <http://www.csulb.edu/~txie/azi/page1.htm>.

Wang, Youxuan. "Configuration of Radicals in the Chinese Characters". Intensive Chinese. 2011-10-25. URL: <http://intensive-chinese.blogspot.com/2011/10/spatial-relations-among-radicals-in.html>.

Wang, Youxuan. "Five Basic Strokes and their Serial Code". Intensive Chinese. 2011-11-12. URL: <http://intensive-chinese.blogspot.com/2011/11/stroke-code-and-stroke-order.html>.

Wang, Youxuan. "The Most Common Radicals in the Chinese Characters".  Intensive Chinese. 2011-10-21. URL: <http://intensive-chinese.blogspot.com/2011/10/shortlist-of-most-common-characters.html>.

Wang, Youxuan. "The stroke orders of '万' and '五': on the etymological basis of the rules." Handian Discussion Forum. 2011-12-15.  URL: <http://bbs.zdic.net/redirect.php?goto=findpost&ptid=157186&pid=532723>. (Posted in Chinese under my penname 心物和.)

Online dictionaries:
Xinhua zidian 《新华字典》. URL: <http://xh.5156edu.com/bs.html>.

Handian 汉典. URL: <http://www.zdic.net/>.


.


No comments:

Post a Comment